It will depend some on what you want to do with the car - will it be a daily driver, or a weekend car? Street and/or autocross and/or track? Do you value brute acceleration over cornering and balance?

I'm moving from a 996 turbo to a Cayman because I like to autocross, and the turbo is a frustrating car to autocross... surreal on the track, and and ridiculous crossing the Nevada desert on Hwy 50 last summer, well into triple digits, but frustrating to autocross. The Cayman will solve that and be almost as much fun on the track.

Both will give you a great driving experience. I agree with Alan, drive them both and make the decision that way.

brad

__________________
21-year PCA Member
PCA DE Instructor